Makes about 30 cookies
- ½ cup butter/margarine
- ½ cup granulated sugar
- ½ cup firmly packed light brown sugar
- ½ cup Nutella
- 1 egg
- ½ tsp. vanilla
- 1 ½ cups flour
- 1 tsp. baking soda
- ¼ tsp. salt
- 1/3 cup chocolate chips
- Preheat oven to 350F.
- Cream butter with an electric mixer about 1 minute (or with a fork) until smooth. Add in both sugars. Beat on high speed about 3 minutes (or with a fork) until light & fluffy, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed.
- With the mixer on low (or with a fork), add the egg and Frangelico (or vanilla). Then add the Nutella and mix well.
- In a small bowl whisk together the flour, baking soda, and salt. Add dry ingredients to wet ingredients, and mix on low speed (or with any utensil) until incorporated. Increase the speed to medium and mix just until the dough is smooth. Fold in chocolate chips.
- Using a small ice cream scoop (or your clean hands) form the dough into balls and place on greased cookie sheet. To prevent my cookies from spreading too much, I stuck the cookie sheets in the freezer for about 10 minutes before baking.
- Bake 6-7 minutes (or 7-8 if baking from freezer). Let cookies cool about 5 minutes and transfer to a rack to cool completely.
The Process:
This. Was. Quite the hullabaloo, actually.
I was going to say debacle, but a quick visit to my Dictionary App said that the negative connatation wasn't just my lack of English knowledge, it was the actual word. So let's just say it's havoc. Seven freshman (eventually eight) trapped in a tiny dorm kitchen with minimal supplies? We mixed the wet ingredients in cereal bowls and the whole thing in a punch dish. Thus, chaos.
Overall, it worked well. Our Zumba-master was a pro at creaming butter with a fork, and managed to work in the Nutella and eggs as well in an average-sized cereal bowl using only a fork. Though, it deserves to be noted, mixing Nutella is a TASK. The goop is thick and hard to deal with, but working it in with the sugars and butter prevailed and we had a delicious concoction right there.
Dry ingredients are basic - make sure you mix the salt and baking soda up a lot so it doesn't all end up in one space! One patch of bitter is no good.
The cooking ended up being where the chaos in cooking and not just cramped space was. At first, we looked to our two teaspoons to help us make the cookie balls, but we caved and just ended up using our hands like if we had made cake balls. The first batch, which we did not freeze at all and let cook for about 5 minutes, since our oven is notorious for cooking quickly, spread out like no body's business. The ends were crunchy, the middle practically raw, and it was not the best result.
The second try didn't yield much better results, even after giving the dough a 10 minute time-out in the freezer. The cookies looked thick and fluffy at first (5 minutes in), but after letting them cook for two minutes more (so sue us, we got caught up in conversation), there was nothing we could do to save them. They already showed the signs over over-cooked, with the edges crisp and the center quickly cooking. We rushed to save them, and managed to salvage them for the people who like not-totally-gooey cookies.
The third batch, which we had kept in the freezer until this point, about 25 minutes in, were the best. We turned down the heat to about 300, then pulled them out when they looked somewhat cooked on the edges, but still thick and fluffy. As they finished cooking and cooled on the tray, we watched them flatten out, but they were definitely delicious. We did not use mini-chocolate chips, so the dough definitely flattened around the bigger chocolate chips and left yummy lumps in our cookies.
Sure, fresh out of the oven, they kind of looked like old, wrinkly cookie-people. However, they were delicious! I wouldn't declare this cookie recipe a total success, since there seem to be a few kinks to work out, but it's something to invest in.
We are planning on trying again sometime in the future, and hoping to maybe add more flour. The dough seemed pretty runny or thin at some points, and we think adding more flour may solve that problem. However, even the website examples that we took this recipe don't seem particularly thick, so maybe that's just the cookie.
Overall, it was a fun experience. Even if the Nutella isn't an obvious flavor at first bite and the cookies at first looked a bit unappealing, it was fun and low-maintenance compared to last weeks entire meal. Cooking/cleaning/eating was really a pleasure for everyone involved, and I was happy to make a meal with such great friend. A special shout out to my roomie, just because she loves food blogs. C:
Until next time, probably when the sister and I reunite over a stove. Stay safe in this cold weather that's all over the news!
Quick Note I found this recipe on Erin's Food Files, so thanks for giving me access to cookies using my favorite food of ALL TIME.
Quick Note I found this recipe on Erin's Food Files, so thanks for giving me access to cookies using my favorite food of ALL TIME.